| Latavia Thomas, NJNY Track Club | 2:00.99 | 2015 |
| Lindsey Butterworth, New Balance | 2:01.13 | 2018 |
| Lauren Wallace, Oiselle | 2:01.13 | 2015 |
| Heather Kampf, Asics | 2:01.48 | 2014 |
| Shannon Leinert, Speed Factory Athletics | 2:01.62 | 2015 |
| Heather Kampf, Asics | 2:01.96 | 2013 |
| Shannon Leinert, Big River Running Company | 2:02.14 | 2013 |
| Kendra Chambers, Oiselle | 2:02.18 | 2018 |
| Jessica Smith, Royal Valley AC | 2:02.22 | 2013 |
| Lauren Wallace, Oiselle | 2:02.25 | 2014 |
